our greatest blessings come to us by way of madness Phaedr. 244a

2012/06/20

ya think?

George Lakoff gives us a synopsis of his recent work, which also happens to be a brilliant in-a-nutshell of the rational, the principles, of our reasons that so lead us away from ourselves: our basic misunderstanding of how we think.
And I don't think I've ever seen a better thumbnail of all that Carl Jung was trying to clue us into. Understand this and it all comes clear.

Just read, please:
[...] There is a received view of mind, absorbed into popular culture and similar to that of the philosopher René Descartes, that I refer to as "Enlightenment reason". It goes like this: reason is conscious, disembodied, dispassionate, literal (it fits the world directly), logical (it leads from facts to correct conclusions), universal and serves self-interest.
This is widely taken as defining "rationality". I surveyed results from neuroscience and the cognitive sciences that contradict all these supposed properties.
Reason is mostly unconscious and physical - it uses the brain. It requires emotion and uses frames, metaphors and melodramatic narratives. It also varies depending on world view and is used at least as much in the service of empathy as self-interest.
This is real reason, how people really think, and it requires a new account of rationality that calls for a New Enlightenment.
Each of these results is crucial for understanding politics. Conservatives, using marketing techniques taken from psychology, have marketed their big ideas effectively: the nature of national security, government, the market, taxes, responsibility, family values, religion, and so on.
Progressives have failed to build institutions (such as think tanks) to get their big ideas out in public honestly. An awareness of brain mechanisms could help map effective communication.
The Political Mind [The Political Mind: Why You Can't Understand 21st-Century American Politics with an 18th-Century Brain] is an exercise in the democratisation of knowledge. It opens up the cognitive science of politics for all to see. Journalists, policy-makers, most economists, and even many academics are stuck on the old view of reason, which leads them to fall prey to effective political marketing, mostly from the conservative side.
Cognitive Science and Linguistics, University of California, Berkeley
From issue 2663 of New Scientist magazine, 02 July 2008, page 20



Now. Marry that to below. And trust, Gnow, grok, take heart, mateys: WE CAN FIX THIS.
Fantastic misgovernment is not an accident, nor is it the work of a few bad individuals. It is the consequence of triumph by a particular philosophy of government, by a movement that understands the liberal state as a perversion and considers the market the ideal nexus of human society. This movement is friendly to industry not just by force of campaign contributions but by conviction; it believes in entrepreneurship not merely in commerce but in politics; and the inevitable results of its ascendance are, first, the capture of the state by business and, second, what follows from that: incompetence, graft, and all the other wretched flotsam that we've come to expect from Washington.
The correct diagnosis is the "bad apple" thesis turned upside down. There are plenty of good conservative individuals, honorable folks who would never participate in the sort of corruption we have watched unfold over the past few years. Hang around with grassroots conservative voters in Kansas, and in the main you will find them to be honest, hardworking people.
But put conservatism in charge of the state, and it behaves very differently. Now the "values" that rightist politicians eulogize on the stump disappear, and in their place we can discern an entirely different set of priorities-priorities that reveal more about the unchanging historical essence of American conservatism than do its fleeting campaigns against gay marriage or secular humanism.
The conservatism that speaks to us through its actions in Washington is institutionally opposed to those baseline good intentions we learned about in elementary school: Its leaders laugh off the idea of the public interest as airy-fairy nonsense; they caution against bringing topnotch talent into government service; they declare war on public workers. They have made a cult of outsourcing and privatizing, they have wrecked established federal operations because they disagree with them, and they have deliberately piled up an Everest of debt in order to force the government into crisis. The ruination they have wrought has been thorough; it has been a professional job. Repairing it will require years of political action. ~Thomas Frank, in the August 2008 edition of Harper's, excerpted from The WRECKING CREW, How a gang of right-wing can men destroyed Washington and made a killing

---------------

Harpers, SEE ALSO: Angola; Apartheid; Career as Angolan guerrilla leader; Career as superspy; Career as U.S. president; Career in conservative politics; Career in politics; Conservatism; Williamson, Craig; Entrepreneurship; Norquist, Grover Glenn; Guerrilla warfare; Iran-Contra Affair, 1985-1990; Iran Hostage Crisis, 1979-1981; Abramoff, Jack; Kemp, Jack; Savimbi, Jonas Malheiro; 1981-1989; North, Oliver; Pictorial works; Political corruption; Reed, Ralph; Republican Party (U.S. : 1854- ); Reagan, Ronald; South Africa


more George Lakoff related articles in New Scientist

1.
Visceral politics
The World's No.1 Science & Technology News Service Visceral politics George Lakoff, Berkeley, California, US Owen Flanagan's description of my book The Political Mind: Why you can't understand 21st...
George Lakoff, 02 July 2008 From magazine issue 2663 Labeled: Letters
2.
Review: The Political Mind by George Lakoff
...Review: The Political Mind by George Lakoff Owen Flanagan Book Details...an 18th-century brain by George Lakoff Viking Penguin $25.95...9780670019274 IN The Political Mind, George Lakoff, an eminent cognitive linguist...
Owen Flanagan, 28 May 2008 From magazine issue 2658 Labeled: Review opinion
3.
Perspectives: Meaning and the body
...it? For nearly three decades, George Lakoff, a linguist from the University... In Philosophy in the Flesh, Lakoff and I explained embodied cognition...different meaning-making patterns. Lakoff and I have called these bodily patterns...
Mark Johnson, 12 January 2008 From magazine issue 2638 Labeled: Perspectives opinion
4.
Grasp the meaning
...experiences, as by the support this gives to an established paradigm in cognitive linguistics: that concepts are embodied. George Lakoff, a pioneer in cognitive linguistics, has long claimed that concepts are generally based on our bodily experience...
Bo Jin, 16 June 2007 From magazine issue 2608 Labeled: Letters
5.
Metaphors sell
...Milton Keynes, UK It's good to see George Lakoff's work on metaphor receiving the attention...military occupation of the Middle East? George Orwell warned us about all this half a century ago. Lakoff's work raises the issue again. It...
Russell Johnston, 18 October 2003 From magazine issue 2417 Labeled: Letters
6.
How does the brain 'think big'?
...Metaphorically speaking, that is. George Lakoff, a cognitive linguist at the University...and breathing, for example. Lakoff's research has led him to believe...using these kinds of metaphors, and Lakoff says he has found thousands of similar...
Anil Ananthaswamy, 27 September 2003 From magazine issue 2414 Labeled: Features

7.
Bestsellers
...Newberg, Ballantine 4 Euclid's Window by Leonard Mlodinow, Free Press 5 Where Mathematics Comes From by George Lakoff, Basic Books 6 Rivers in Time by Peter Ward, Columbia University Press 7 The Quantum Brain by Jeffrey...
16 June 2001 From magazine issue 2295 Labeled: Opinion
8.
Bestsellers
...Himanen, Random House 2 Where Mathematics Comes From by George Lakoff, Basic Books 3 Crypto by Steven Levy, Viking/Penguin...Cole, Harcourt 9 The Universal History of Computing by Georges Ifrah, Wiley 10 Quantum Evolution by Johnjoe McFadden...
31 March 2001 From magazine issue 2284 Labeled: Opinion
9.
Bestsellers from San Francisco
...Mathematics Comes From by George Lakoff, Basic Books 2 Robo...Universal History of Computing by Georges Ifrah, John Wiley 8 Telecosm by George Gilder, Free Press 9...Oxford University Press George Gilder is known for his maverick...
03 February 2001 From magazine issue 2276 Labeled: Opinion